"H O N E S T"  E D D I E 'S  T A P  R O O M



View Accommodations

Honest Eddie's Bar

The Maple Room Restaurant

Make a Reservation

Area Attractions

Banquets & Weddings

History of Hancock


Our Other Lodgings

Contact Us


Located off the main reception area on the main floor you will find Honest Eddie's. The name was inspired by, and named in honor of John Edward Murphy, who was born on Friday, October 2, 1891, in Hancock, New York, little more than 100 yards from the front door of The Hancock House.

The doors open at Honest Eddie's Tap Room at 12 noon every day of the week.

If you need something to help wash down the beer, you can order from a variety of delicious food. Everything from Burgers to Soup is available from The Maple Room kitchen. Current Food Menu available on Facebook.    

To order online, click here.


About "Honest" Eddie Murphy

Murphy was a teammate of Shoeless Joe Jackson when they played for the infamous Chicago "Black Sox". It was here, after the 1919 World Series that Eddie would receive the nickname of "Honest" Eddie Murphy.

When 8 of his teammates were accused of fixing the 1919 World Series, Eddie would not be tainted by the scandal and was known from that day on as "Honest" Eddie Murphy.


He played in a total of 3 World Series, an honor most of today's multimillion dollar ball players can only dream of.  Eddie Murphy broke into the big leagues on August 26, 1912. His rookie year was played with Connie Mack's Philadelphia Athletics posting a batting average of .317. The following year he appeared in his first World Series when the A's faced the New York Giants. He would later lace up spikes for the Chicago White Sox and Pittsburgh Pirates.

When Babe Ruth made his debut as a pitcher the first batter Ruth faced was Eddie Murphy from Hancock, New York. Murphy had much in common with Ruth. Both of their parents were in the "saloon" business. It is only fitting that this “Saloon”, or as Eddie liked to call it, “Beer Garden”, would bare his name a century later.
In 1918 Ruth and Murphy had nearly identical batting averages. Ruth finished the season with .300 and Murphy with .297.

Eddie Murphy ended his career with a lifetime batting average of .287. Even Murphy's batboy, Gabe Paul, would go on to fame as the General Manager of the New York Yankees.

Honest Eddie Murphy played 11 years in professional baseball with the Philadelphia Athletics, Chicago White Sox and the Pittsburgh Pirates.
But he never forgot where he came from.

A small room over a tavern in Hancock, New York.